Scott Neu, a former sheriff's deputy who was fired in 2015 for allegedly forcing jail inmates to fight each other, and costing the city some $280,000 in settlements, is being rehired by the Sheriff's Office.
Though Neu was criminally charged by former District Attorney George Gascón in 2016 with 17 criminal counts, these charges were dropped after the Sheriff's Office allegedly destroyed evidence in the case; in one instance an investigator's laptop was smashed with a hammer due to a virus.
Neu is being reinstated to his former position -- in which he worked in the county jail -- the City Attorney's Office confirmed today.
The reinstatement comes after Neu and the deputy sheriffs' union in 2021 successfully compelled the city to participate in binding arbitration regarding his firing. The use of this alternative to the court system is written into the union's contract with the city. Neu's appeal hearing was held in August 2023, and the arbitrator overseeing it subsequently opted to reduce his termination to a 90-day suspension.
The arbitrator's decision is binding, and the city is legally obligated to comply with it.
Jail detainee Quincy Lewis in 2018 received a $60,000 settlement after he alleged that Neu forced him to fight other inmates, gamble, or do pushups for food. Ricardo Palikiko-Garcia was in 2016 paid $90,000 in a settlement over his case alleging that he was forced to fight a fellow inmate for food by Neu and other deputies, who took bets on winners.
Neu allegedly told inmates to say they fell off their bunk if they got injured during the fights, and threatened to beat or mace the inmates to compel them to fight, Gascón said at the time.
But before the "fight club" cases, Neu was also accused of sexual assault by detainees David Spears, Sabrina Wigfall, and Kyle Adams between 2004 and 2008. The city settled their suits for a total of $95,000. And in 2006, Neu was accused of punching and kicking an inmate in his cell, leaving him with two broken ribs, but was not disciplined or criminally charged.
Public Defender Mano Raju:
The fact that Neu will be back at his old job and in a position to potentially engage in the same violent and abusive behavior is deeply disturbing, and it's a slap in the face to our clients and their families who bravely reported his abuses years ago. This reinstatement illustrates that members of law enforcement agencies are effectively immunized from any meaningful consequences for their misconduct because of protections under state law and local policies they have obtained through heavy lobbying. This must end.
For the sake of our clients, their families, and the San Franciscans who had to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in settlements to Neu's victims, I demand to know what steps the Sheriff is taking to ensure Neu is not in a position to have contact and authority over anyone detained in county jail. The Sheriff can and should recommend Neu for decertification under state law, and I urge the Sheriff Oversight Board and the new Inspector General to take a close look at the department's practices and policies to ensure nothing like this ever happens again.
We encourage the public to view the extensive investigative materials our office has collected on Neu in our Cop Monitor database, which was specifically created to shine a light on law enforcement misconduct, such as Neu's 'fight club,' that rarely see the light of day.
Previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously.
The Mission's response to homelessness: More than 2,000 planters:
A little girl was run over and killed at a location where Caltrans and SFCTA now want to pump in more high-speed traffic through a freeway ramp widening. Then they wonder why Vision Zero is failing.
Cruse "autonomous"vehicles require 1.5 drivers, and manual intervention every two and a half miles:
2016, just before the election:
2019: Halloween, Night Five:
Opposition grows to Breed's APEC boosterism:
Cruise Self-Driving License Revoked After It Withheld Pedestrian Injury Footage.
San Francisco passes strongest vacant housing speculation tax: