Mourning Herp Derp

I am so sad that the Herp Derp YouTube Comments plugin no longer works:

YouTube's new commenting system is using frames and currently breaks Herp Derp. I have no plans to bring it back in the near future.

From my estimates Herp Derp was downloaded 30,000+ times!

Download Removed

Previously, previously, previously.

Tags: , , , ,

14 Responses:


  2. Andy Goth says:

    What difference does it make? The comments all say "herp derp" all the time anyway, no plugin needed

  3. Geoff Smith says:

    Well, for one, it helps eliminate spoilers on videos. I've seen some where the top-rated comment that ended up right below the video spoiled the entire video for me.

  4. Jason Scott says:

    R.I.P. Herp Derp, you were one of my favorite plugins of all times, and saved me so much stress.

    • plumpy says:

      I also thoroughly enjoyed how confused people were when they watched YouTube videos on my computer, trying to figure out why everyone was writing nearly identical gibberish comments. (Nearly all of them thought it was hilarious when I explained it was just an extension.)

      • John says:

        Odd, seemed to me everyone on Youtube was making nearly-identical gibberish comments even before the plugins to eliminate comments.

        • Pavel Lishin says:

          Sure, but it was weaponized nonsense, demanding brain cycles from me to parse their gibberish while offering nothing in return.

          Herp derp is just... jolly.

  5. Jay Sittler says:

    I miss that plugin...

  6. Otto says:

    Since it is no longer possible to comment on YouTube without connecting it to your Google+ account, the comments are now basically useless anyway. People who have something meaningful to say are prevented from saying it anyway.

    An extension to simply remove comments is far more useful and easier to do.

  7. Requiring people to sign up for the Plusterfuck before letting them comment on youtube videos has roughly the same effect as HerpDerp did, although I certainly miss it style-wise.

  8. Anthony says:

    No more Herp Derp on YouTube. And the internet just got a little dumber.

  9. David Glover says:

    Comment Snob doesn't work either. I am sad.

  • Previously