jwz: 13-Jan-2003 (Mon)

[...] Palm, Inc., announced today that future versions of Palm OS will not contain Graffiti. Rather, they will incorporate a modified version of Communication Intelligence Corporation's Jot handwriting recognition software, something it's calling Graffiti 2 powered by Jot.
The impetus for the switch appears to be legal rather than technical. In April 1997, Xerox sued Palm, claiming that Graffiti was essentially derived from its patented Unistrokes technology. [...] in late 2001, Xerox won a reversal in the U.S. Court of Appeals and the lawsuit was back on, and it's been hanging over Palm's head ever since.
CIC's Jot recognition software has long been found on competing handhelds running on the Pocket PC platform. As with Graffiti, its alphabet is based on block characters. However, unlike Graffiti, some characters require two rather than one stroke. Therefore, Jot characters more closely resemble common block letters than Graffiti characters.

Update: Time for Palm to switch to the Dasher "zooming" thing? Opinion from those who know seems to be that CIC/Jot is far inferior to Graffiti. So this is just such a perfect example of the true effect of patents:

Both companies waste a huge amount of money in litigation;
The taxpayers waste a huge amount of money running the courts;
When the patent holder "wins" their extortion case, the defendant either goes out of business, or just switches to a less-encumbered yet less-good technology;
And the ultimate loser? The customers.

But if we can save just one revenue stream, won't it all have been worth it?

Tags: copyright

Current Music: The Damage Manual -- Top Ten Severed ♬

zooming, predictive text entry!

20 years ago

"Dasher: Attack of the killer alphabets"

"Dasher is a zooming interface. You point where you want to go, and the display zooms in wherever you point. The world into which you are zooming is painted with letters, so that any point you zoom in on corresponds to a piece of text. The more you zoom in, the longer the piece of text you have written. You choose what you write by choosing where to zoom.
To make the interface efficient, we use the predictions of a language model to determine how much of the world is devoted to each piece of text. Probable pieces of text are given more real-estate, so they are quick and easy to select. Improbable pieces of text (for example, text with spelling mistakes) are given less space, so they are harder to write. The language model learns all the time: if you use a novel word once, it is easier to write next time."

8 Comments