Badger-Bluff Fanny Freddie versus Ensenada Taboo Planet-Et

The Perfect Milk Machine: How Big Data Transformed the Dairy Industry

Before he had a single daughter producing milk, the United States Department of Agriculture took a look at his lineage and more than 50,000 markers on his genome and declared Badger-Bluff Fanny Freddie the best bull in the land. And, three years and 346 milk- and data-providing daughters later, it turns out that they were right. [...]

The bull market (heh) can be reduced to one key statistic, lifetime net merit [...] When you add it all up, Badger-Fluff Fanny Freddie has a net merit of $792. No other proven sire ranks above $750 and only seven bulls in the country rank above $700. One might assume that this is largely because the bull can help the cows make more milk, but it's not! While breeders used to select for greater milk production, that's no longer considered the most important trait. For example, the number three bull in America is named Ensenada Taboo Planet-Et. His predicted transmitting ability for milk production is +2323, more than 1100 pounds greater than Freddie. His offspring's milk will likely containmore protein and fat as well. But his daughters' productive life would be shorter and their pregnancy rate is lower. And these factors, as well as some traits related to the hypothetical daughters' size and udder quality, trump Planet's impressive production stats.

One reason for the change in breeding emphasis is that our cows already produce tremendous amounts of milk relative to their forbears. In 1942, when my father was born, the average dairy cow produced less than 5,000 pounds of milk in its lifetime. Now, the average cow produces over 21,000 pounds of milk. At the same time, the number of dairy cows has decreased from a high of 25 million around the end of World War II to fewer than nine million today. This is an indisputable environmental win as fewer cows create less methane, a potent greenhouse gas, and require less land. [...]

While we may worry about the use of antibiotics to stimulate animal growth or the use of hormones to increase milk production by up to 25 percent, most of the increase in the pounds of milk an animal puts out over the pastoral days of yore come from the genetic changes that we've wrought within these animals. It doesn't matter how the cow is raised -- in an idyllic pasture or a feedlot -- either way, the animal of 2012 is not the animal of 1940 or 1980 or even 2000. A group of USDA and University of Minnesota scientists calculated that 22 percent of the genome of Holstein cattle has been altered by human selection over the last 40 years. [...]

No matter how you apportion the praise or blame, the net effect is the same. Thousands of years of qualitative breeding on family-run farms begat cows producing a few thousand pounds of milk in their lifetimes; a mere 70 years of quantitative breeding optimized to suit corporate imperatives quadrupled what all previous civilization had accomplished. And the crazy thing is, we're at the cusp of a new era in which genomic data starts to compress the cycle of trait improvement, accelerating our path towards the perfect milk-production machine, also known as the Holstein dairy cow.

Previously, previously, previously, previously.

Tags: , ,

10 Responses:

  1. David M.A. says:

    Is it weird that I find the measurement of milk in pounds instead of gallons weird?

    • mspong says:

      It's especially weird because high fat content milk, which is desired, would weigh less per litre than watery milk.

      • Rainbird says:

        If you have high butter fat content milk, you sell on a different market with higher prices than just the regular market. If you have low fat content on the regular market, you get docked in the price they pay you.

    • Leolo says:

      What's more, it's pounds of milk fat, not pounds of liquid.

    • Rainbird says:

      It is easier to measure pounds. If you want o measure gallons you have to pump it through a meter. --And each time you pump the milk you fracture fat gobules and lead to early spoilage. If you want to measure pounds, just roll the truck across a scale.

  2. I am worried they might be creating a monocowture.

  3. bq Mackintosh says:

    My god. It's full of cows.